ReleaseLaw.com

 

Online Waiver Agreements:
Not Worth The Paper They’re (Not) Written On?
By Alexander “Sandie” Pendleton

Do courts enforce waiver agreements that are entered into between parties electronically, for instance, via an online registration process?  Or instead, will courts only find an agreement enforceable if the agreement is printed on a real piece of paper and signed in ink in the traditional manner?

The above questions raise a host of issues, and there is no one definitive answer (this is due partly to the fact that the enforceability of any waiver agreement is dependent on multiple considerations, including which state’s laws apply to a given accident or waiver agreement).  Online waiver agreements can raise such issues as:

  • What constitutes “consent” sufficient to form a binding contract?
  • Is it necessary for a party to have actually read the terms of a proposed contract, if the party signed (or otherwise expressed the party’s consent to the written terms of) the proposed contract?
  • What constitutes a sufficient “signature” for purposes of an online agreement, and how does one prove a particular person clicked on “I agree,” if the person later claimed it must have been someone else (or his dog)?
  • When the terms of the contract and the consent to the contract all exist electronically, how does one prove that after the fact, the terms were not changed, so that a court will find authentic and permit into evidence a particular document?
  • If data is lost (due to a crash, for instance, or just normal deletion policies), what proof will courts accept to prove the terms of the purported agreement?

There is a long history of the courts struggling with similar issues as each new means of electronic communication arrives (e.g., the telegraph, the telephone, Twitter, etc.).

While discussions of the above issues fill legal textbooks and law review articles, what can be said in the recreational release context is that courts have enforced online waiver agreements, even in instances where the actual “original” online agreement was later “lost.”  For example, in a 2009 Minnesota Court of Appeals case, the court allowed enforcement of an online waiver agreement, even though the defendant lost the 2005 version of the “original” agreement, and could only produce the 2007 version (with testimony by an individual that the terms of the 2005 form and the 2007 form were the same).

Online registration forms and procedures provide certain benefits to organizations and businesses that use them, but also carry with them certain risks.  There are definitely “bad” online waiver-of-liability forms that are currently being used by organizations to register new members and participants, which forms would not be enforced by courts (especially in such “strict” states as Wisconsin).  If you are using (or considering the using) an online registration process, we suggest that you consult with a lawyer who is familiar with the above issues, and has experience with designing online forms and procedures.

PDF Version

© 2013 Pendleton Legal, S.C.

250 E. Wisconsin Ave. Suite 1800  Milwaukee, WI 53202  |  Telephone: 414.418.4469  |  Email: pendleton@pendletonlegal.com

 

michael kors black friday michael kors black friday michael kors Black Friday michael kors Black Friday uggs Black Friday michael kors black friday lululemon black friday kate spade cyber monday kate spade cyber monday coach black Friday kate spade cyber monday burberry black friday Dior cyber monday gucci black friday coach black Friday Babyliss black friday lululemon black friday michael kors black friday canada goose black friday uggs black friday beats by dre cyber Monday uggs black friday uggs black Friday north face cyber Monday michael kors black friday uggs black Friday beats by dre black friday beats by dre cyber Monday beats by dre cyber Monday beats by dre cyber Monday coach cyber monday michael kors black friday beats by dre cyber Monday lululemon black friday uggs cyber monday beats by dre cyber Monday uggs black friday beats by dre black friday jordan cyber monday canada goose black friday north face cyber Monday beats by dre cyber Monday michael kors black Friday north face black friday Babyliss black Friday beats by dre cyber Monday michael kors cyber Monday michael kors black Friday north face cyber monday michael kors black Friday michael kors cyber Monday beats by dre cyber Monday moncler cyber monday michael kors cyber Monday Herve Leger black friday michael kors cyber Monday tory burch black Friday beats by dre cyber Monday uggs cyber monday michael kors cyber Monday north face cyber monday Babyliss black Friday michael kors cyber Monday lululemon cyber monday michael kors black Friday nike cyber monday beats by dre cyber Monday jordan black friday kate spade black friday uggs black friday gucci cyber monday north face black friday north face black friday sale lululemon black friday lululemon cyber monday Oakley cyber Monday michael kors black Friday uggs cyber monday Babyliss black Friday beats by dre cyber Monday uggs cyber monday canada goose black friday michael kors cyber Monday kate spade black friday beats by dre black Friday canada goose cyber monday kate spade black friday jordan 13 bred michael kors black Friday canada goose cyber monday coach cyber monday canada goose cyber monday beats by dre cheap jordan 6 black infrared jordan 13 bred north face black Friday uggs cyber monday Polo Ralph Lauren cyber monday uggs cyber monday uggs cyber monday michael kors cyber monday kate spade black friday beats by dre black Friday beats by dre black Friday michael kors cyber monday michael kors cyber monday jordan 11 legend blue beats by dre black Friday Abercrombie And Fitch black friday uggs black Friday uggs black Friday canada goose cyber monday north face black Friday hollister black friday legend blue 11s black infrared 6s hollister black friday lululemon cyber monday uggs cyber monday uggs cyber monday true religion black friday kate spade cyber monday beats by dre black Friday legend blue 11s canada goose black friday true religion black friday michael kors black Friday true religion black friday jordan 6 black infrared lululemon black friday michael kors black Friday uggs cyber Monday michael kors cyber monday legend blue 11s beats by dre black Friday black infrared 6s north face black Friday gucci cyber monday uggs cyber monday victoria secret cyber monday gucci cyber monday jordan cyber monday north face outlet hollister black friday lululemon cyber monday jordan cyber monday