ReleaseLaw.com

 

Indiana Court Dismisses Horse-Kick Case
Based on Equine Activity Statute
By Alexander “Sandie” Pendleton

On August 16, 2010, the Indiana Court of Appeals upheld a lower court’s dismissal of a personal injury case brought by a person injured when a horse kicked her at a 4-H Club horse show. The court in Perry v. Whitley County 4-H Clubs, Inc. held that the defendant had complied with Indiana’s Equine Activity Statute, and that the statute provided immunity to the club.

In 2007, the plaintiff, Teresa Perry, was helping out at a 4-H horse show. She had extensive experience with horses and horse shows. The building at which the horse show was conducted had at its entrance a “equine activity warning” sign consistent with the signs required by Indiana’s equine activity statute, and Perry admitted later that she had seen the sign. In the course of the show, Perry believed a child who was showing one of the horses was in a dangerous position behind another horse, and when Perry stepped in to try to remedy the situation, her knee was kicked by the horse.

Perry commenced a lawsuit against the 4-H club, arguing that the club was negligent in several ways. The club sought summary judgment based on the Indiana Equine Activity Statute, and the trial court granted summary judgment, finding that being kicked is “an inherent risk” of equine activity, and that there was no evidence of reckless conduct by the club.

On appeal, the court of appeals affirmed. Noting that the Equine Activity Statute had not previously been interpreted in any prior Indiana reported cases, the court looked to decisions from other states interpreting similar statutes. The court first noted that Perry did not attempt to argue that any of the statute’s exceptions to immunity (e.g., faulty tack, latent premises defect, reckless disregard, or intentional injury) applied. The court then went on to discuss whether the statute should be interpreted as applying to negligent behavior of equine activity sponsors. The court begins its analysis by noting that the statute does not expressly indicate it protects sponsors from all negligence claims, but then goes on to conclude that a negligence action is precluded if the injury resulted from an “inherent risk of equine activities.”  Turning to the facts at hand, the court concluded that the unpredictability of horses, and their propensity to kick, are inherent risks of equine activities.

Overall, the decision is a helpful one for businesses and organizations that work with horses. The lesson of the case is that organizations should ensure that they become aware of the details of equine activity and other recreational immunity statutes in their states, and then ensure they structure their activities so as to maximize the chances that such statutes will provide immunity. Equine activity immunity statutes vary considerably from state to state, with some potentially providing substantial protection, and some providing practically no protection. Likewise, many recreational immunity statutes are detailed creating several different categories of protected parties. Recreational immunity decisions often turn on small factual details. Parties wishing to ensure their operations are structured so as to be protected by recreational immunity statutes should review their operations with legal counsel, and obtain a written opinion as to the scope of protection such statutes may provide.

If we can assist you with protecting your organization from unnecessary liability, do not hesitate to contact us.

 

PDF Version

© 2013 Pendleton Legal, S.C.

250 E. Wisconsin Ave. Suite 1800  Milwaukee, WI 53202  |  Telephone: 414.418.4469  |  Email: pendleton@pendletonlegal.com

 

michael kors black friday michael kors black friday michael kors black friday michael kors Black Friday michael kors Black Friday michael kors black friday hollister cyber monday Abercrombie and fitch cyber monday lululemon cyber monday lululemon cyber monday hollister black friday tory burch black friday Babyliss black friday Babyliss black friday tory burch black friday Tiffany cyber monday uggs cyber monday beats by dre cyber Monday michael kors black friday michael kors black friday beats by dre black Friday michael kors black friday beats by dre cyber Monday north face cyber Monday uggs cyber monday coach black Friday michael kors black Friday nike cyber monday true religion cyber monday north face black friday beats by dre black friday uggs black friday kate spade black friday moncler black friday uggs cyber monday kate spade cyber monday lululemon cyber monday Victoria Secret cyber monday uggs black friday canada goose black friday uggs cyber monday coach black friday coach black friday celine black friday north face cyber monday uggs cyber monday north face cyber monday beats by dre cyber Monday north face cyber monday Tiffany black Friday canada goose black friday coach black friday chanel cyber monday chanel cyber monday michael kors black Friday beats by dre cyber Monday Polo cyber monday lululemon cyber monday uggs cyber monday canada goose cyber monday black friday jordans moncler cyber monday the north face black friday the north face black friday beats by dre cyber Monday Babyliss black Friday north face cyber monday Hollister cyber Monday under armour black friday michael kors black friday lululemon cyber monday coach cyber monday coach cyber monday north face cyber monday michael kors black Friday uggs cyber monday Ugg boots cyber monday uggs black friday uggs cyber monday uggs black friday uggs black friday Victoria Secret cyber monday lululemon black friday michael kors black Friday beats by dre cyber Monday kate spade cyber monday uggs black Friday bred 13s louis vuitton outlet jordan 6 black infrared lululemon cyber Monday jordan 11 legend blue Abercrombie And Fitch black friday michael kors black Friday north face cyber Monday beats by dre cyber Monday victoria secret black friday beats by dre cyber monday michael kors cyber monday uggs cyber monday hollister black friday jordan black friday kate spade cyber monday hollister black friday canada goose cyber monday beats by dre black Friday uggs cyber Monday jordan 11 legend blue north face black Friday black infrared 6s uggs cyber monday michael kors black Friday michael kors black Friday beats by dre cyber Monday michael kors cyber monday lululemon black Friday canada goose black friday hollister cyber monday beats by dre cyber monday uggs cyber monday grey toe 13s kate spade cyber monday north face black friday hollister cyber monday gucci cyber monday kate spade black friday coach outlet online Abercrombie And Fitch black friday jordan 13 bred michael kors cyber monday hollister black friday lululemon black Friday north face black Friday coach cyber Monday lululemon black Friday coach outlet online north face black friday lululemon cyber monday canada goose black friday beats by dre cyber monday uggs cyber monday uggs cyber monday north face black Friday uggs cyber monday uggs cyber monday michael kors cyber monday